We all know that cash balance plans are one of the best retirement strategies on the market. But most people don’t really understand the contribution limits.
People get confused when it comes to minimum and maximum contributions. They also look for clarification on annual and lifetime limits.
In this post, we will answer many of these funding questions. So let’s dive in and look at some basic funding guidelines.Quick Navigation
- What are the plan limits?
- Are the contributions age-weighted?
- What is the lifetime limit?
- What is the Minimum Contribution?
- IRS limit for cash balance plan (annual contribution limits)
- How much can you contribute to a cash balance plan?
- What is the maximum contribution to a cash balance plan?
- Funding Calculation
- Lifetime Contribution Limits
What are the plan limits?
Cash balance plans are a type of defined benefit plan. The annual contribution is generally not fixed and will go up or down depending on a variety of criteria.
The goal is to generate a certain benefit at retirement age. Essentially a cash balance plan is aiming for a retirement amount down the road.
This is in contrast to how a 401(k) works. A 401(k) plan establishes the maximum contribution upfront. They both are retirement savings vehicles. They just go about it a little differently.
Once money is contributed to a 401(k) plan, the account balance could grow to millions of dollars or in theory it go go to zero! For plan compliance purposes, it doesn’t really matter.
A cash balance plan doesn’t really have an annual contribution limit like a 401(k). This is because it is trying to reach a specific amount upon retirement (typically at 62 years old).
The amount of money in the plan at retirement is dependent on certain things. But mostly it depends on your average compensation. Assuming maximum compensation, you can have about $2.9 million upon retirement. A nice chunk of money.
Are the contributions age-weighted?
But the nice part about the plans is that you can contribute more as you get older. So annual contributions will increase with age and higher compensation.
Here’s a closer look at how it works…
Let’s assume for example that there are two hypothetical employees who each make $40,000 annually. One of the employees is age 36 and the other is age 56. In theory, they would both have the same retirement balance at 62 years old.
But the 36 year old has many more years until retirement, as compared to the 56 year old. As such, the company would have to contribute a smaller annual amount.
However, the 56 year old is just 6 years away from retirement age. Accordingly, the company has to make larger contributions to reach the same retirement goal.
Considering a Cash Balance or Defined Benefit Plan?
See if a plan is right for you and your business
This is why the plans can work so well. Most business owners tend to have higher income the older they get. Combine this with the age weighting of the plans and you get the point. Large tax deductible contributions above $100,000 are the norm.
What is the lifetime limit?
Even though cash balance plans may have minimum contributions and maximum contributions, they also have a lifetime limit or a lifetime cap as it is sometimes called.
We actually established what this lifetime limit is in the previous section. It is $2.9 million for 2020. This is up a little from 2019 as it actually changes annually. It is indexed based on mortality rates, etc.
Many employers aren’t really concerned about the lifetime limit because they simply want to maximize contributions. The goal is huge tax deductions and to supercharge retirement savings.
IRS limit for cash balance plan (annual contribution limits)
One question we are asked all the time is: what is the most I can contribute to a cash balance plan? What is the IRS limit?
This question can sometimes get the generic response: it depends. But we can give you a good idea how much if you want to push the annual contribution limits.
There is technically no annual contribution limit for a cash balance plan. Instead, the ultimate benefit to be paid at retirement is limited.
So if we assume maximum compensation, published mortality rates and an interest rate credit of 5% (pretty standard), we can actually come up with an approximate annual contribution limit for a given age.Are you looking to get over $100,000 into retirement? Get a FREE Illustration showing your contribution and tax savings today. See for yourself why our plans are one of the best tax deferrals!
But be careful. These contribution levels are used for illustration purposes and actual amounts are calculated by an actuary. The IRS limit will also be indexed usually on an annual basis.
However, if you are looking for a general guideline this should do. We will discuss in a bit how to increase these numbers if you are really looking to make a large contribution. But this is a good starting point.
Maximum Annual Contribution Table – 2020
|Age||Maximum Annual Contribution|
The above table is for 2020 and amounts would be different for 2018 and 2019. But let’s take a closer look at the numbers.
For 2020, an employee with 10 years of participation in a cash balance plan can receive a maximum annual benefit payout of $230,000 per year beginning at the age of 62. As previously discussed, the IRS places a limit on compensation used in the calculation of benefits. For 2020, the maximum (which is indexed to the CPI) was $285,000 and for 2019 it was $5,000 lower.Are you looking to get over $100,000 into retirement? Get a FREE Illustration showing your contribution and tax savings today. See for yourself why our plans are one of the best tax deferrals!
Alternatively, they could receive an equivalent lump sum of approximately $2.9 million. The benefit limit applies to single-life annuities that will begin between the ages of 62 and 65, with an adjustment made to reflect the starting age and form of payment.
How much can you contribute to a cash balance plan?
The employer is also vested with the responsibility to invest plan assets for the employees. If the investment doesn’t give the required returns, the employer will be forced to make unanticipated contributions. To avoid this situation, the employer has to make three key investment decisions;
- Asset allocation – this has a huge impact on the returns from an investment as compared to interest crediting rate
- Interest crediting rate – if the rate is high, the plan will have more growth to benefit the participants but may have bigger shortfalls when the target is not achieved.
- Handling shortfalls – if an investment does not give the expected returns, 401(k) and profit sharing contributions can be paused for a year or two to free up funds to finance cash balance plan contributions. Amortization period could also be extended up to a maximum of seven years.
What is the maximum contribution to a cash balance plan?
So we discussed before the annual contribution limits. But that didn’t really tell the whole story. There are ways to get the funding above these levels. But it takes a little planning and quality plan structuring.
The limits are much higher than a 401(k) plan. For 2021, the maximum annual contribution to a 401(k) plan is $58,000 ($64,500 people age 50 and older), while the maximum cash balance plan contribution can reach as high as $341,000.
So I would start with the numbers above and then consider what we would call “prior service” or “past service.” This is a creative strategy to maximize the contribution in a given year.Looking for more information on cash balance plans? Take a look at our ultimate guide to cash balance plans. Discover our favorite strategies!
This only works for a new plan and not the conversion of a plan. It allows the business owner to grant an opening cash balance credit to all eligible employees. This allows you to get more into the plan in year one only.
The credit for past service can be a little complex, but let’s just say that the main requirement is that there was compensation in prior years. For illustrative purposes, you could assume that you could get an opening credit of approximately 50% of the contribution listed in the table above. There are a few other tips and tricks, but let’s just assume that will get you to the cash balance plan maximum contribution.
What is the Minimum Contribution?
I stated before that the #1 question we are asked is typically what the maximum contribution can be. But I think the #2 question we are asked is: what is the minimum cash balance plan contribution?
Why is this? Well most clients are hoping for the best, but also considering any downside. Folks don’t want to be “stuck” in a plan that they are unable to fund. That’s why minimum contributions are often discussed.
But it is usually less of a concern than it should be. In fact, after the first year your plan will generally have a funding range. This would include a low end and high end. So you could simply choose the low end of the range.
In fact, if you have made substantial contributions and your plan has been in place for a few years you may find that you have no minimum funding amount. This is certainly not always the case. But if you think that funding might be an issue, make sure to communicate your concerns with your plan administrator.
Cash balance plan requires optimum investments to benefit participants. These investment goals and strategies should be analyzed and changed at least annually to accommodate any shortfalls.
Plan sponsors should avoid unanticipated contributions towards a plan by doing thorough research before making key decisions on asset allocation, interest crediting rate and handling shortfalls.
Cash Balance Plan Limits: Funding Calculation
The actual funding calculation can be a little challenging. Benefits received are based on the total years of service coupled with the salary for the past few years leading to retirement. An annual credit based on the salary is made to your account, normally 5% and then an interest rate credit is added to your account balance.
The contributions made to a cash balance plan are based on the required amount needed to provide benefits to participants. The amounts are calculated based on actuarial assumptions.
However, any annual benefit for a participant cannot exceed the lower of:
- 100% of the plan participant’s average compensation for the highest 3 consecutive calendar years; or
- $230,000 for calendar year 2020
The IRS establishes annual compensation limits. An employee’s W-2 can be higher than the $285,000 limitation, but the plan actuary can only use this amount for contribution purposes. Compensation will ultimately determine any accumulated retirement plan benefit during retirement.
Lifetime Contribution Limits
The cash balance plan lifetime limit is significantly higher than a 401(k) plan. The difference grows even higher as age also increases. This enables employees to build substantial tax-deferred accounts. Cash balance plans require individuals who earn well, like key employees in medical, law, and accounting practices to take advantage of the contributions and secure retirement portfolios quickly.
Due to the nature of the plan, the calculation works out to the lifetime limit of $2.9 million at age 62. The specific calculation will discount this $2.9 million amount based on the employee age and using an assumed interest rate over a 10-year period.
What is the most I can contribute to a cash balance plan? Contributions toward a cash balance plan can be as high as $300,000 as the participant nears retirement age, subject to their level of income.
How to determine estimated contribution limits:
- Age 40 = $138,158
While our average client is in their early 50’s, at age 40 clients usually start getting interested about saving for retirement. In addition, at this age income will usually start to increase and so will tax liabilities.
- Age 50 = $218,547
In the early 50’s many will begin to ramp up retirement contributions. Clients often realize that a 401k just won’t get an reasonable amount into savings.
- Age 60 = $316,183
At this age retirement is just around the corner. Maximum funding is usually recommended in order to save on taxes and make sure there is adequate savings.
- Determine funding range
Even though the amounts above represent funding limits, you will generally have a minimum and maximum amount. Determine which level makes sense for you depending on taxable income and marginal federal and state tax rates.
- Examine investment balances
Once the contribution is made make sure to monitor the investment returns in order to gauge future funding. High returns will equate to lower future contributions and lower returns will push contributions towards the maximum.
As a result of the higher limits, a business owner can use higher earning years that will to help them catch up on retirement contributions and maximize the tax deduction.